Seek Justice Against Chiquita

I've reached the next modest benchmark in my campaign to raise awareness about Chiquita.  20 blogs have educated their readers about Chiquita pleading guilty to paying almost $2 million to recognized terrorists groups in Colombia.  I would like to use this opportunity to make a humble plea for help, and put forth a passionate defense about why this cause is the right one to take on.

It was an article in the Christian Science Monitor that inspired me to act.  This article made clear that Chiquita was not only paying protection payments, but it might have actually been providing actual physical support by transporting over 3,000 assault rifles.  It also made the human costs of funding paramilitary organizations very clear to me.  Since reading this article I have become even more convinced of the necessity to raise awareness about this injustice and take action.

I'm not going to play any games in this post.  The primary reason I think it is important to act on this is because I believe this case illustrates global inequity more than any other.  This inequity that is not only tacitly accepted, but is actively enforced by the governments of our nations.  The citizens of different nations are not born equal and I believe this campaign has the potential to bring this reality to light and inspire people to do something about it.

But there is so much more that is great about this campaign.  In an increasingly polarized world, discussing an increasingly polarizing subject matter, people of vastly different political persuasions can come together and agree on this injustice.  Just like I think people can agree that the only way that we're really going to solve migration problems on this globe is if we start giving people a reason to stay. 

Recent occurances lead me to believe that this campaign isn't a pie in the sky endeavor, but there is actual political and legal support behind claims for justice in the case of Chiquita.  The media has been excruciatingly slow to cover this but if the media choose to wake up justice will roll down like a roaring waterfall instead of a trickling stream.  There is a possibility for real change here and I am pleading with everyone that is reading this to take a more active role in this campaign.

I'm not going to ask for anything concrete, yet.  I think it's better to continue with my modest goal of getting a hundred blogs to cover this ten at a time.  Still, email me at kyledeb at gmail dot com if your interested in getting involved further.  Something as simple as getting another blog to cover this is extremely helpful. 

I've already been criticized from both sides with this campaign.  I've been accused on the right of being unrealistic and of not taking into account the concerns of U.S. citizens.  On the left I was sent an email that accused me of being patriarchial.  Of arrogantly coopting others causes into my own when I should be supporting others instead of trying to assume a leadership role.  I won't comment on either criticism here except to say that I appreciate them because they help make me stronger, and to say that only God can judge my actions and I can only do what I believe is right in the meantime.

Taking into account these criticisms along with the posts of so many others I'm going to outline actions that I think we should take.

1. Raise Awareness

At this point in time this is really the most effective step that anyone can take.  I've been publicly trying to get blogs to cover this issue, but there is so much more to this course of action.  I've been regularly writing media outlets asking them to cover our campaign.  I've been talking to grocery store managers asking them to talk Chiquita bananas off the shelves.  I've been talking to individuals to educate them about the heinous crimes that have been committed to bring cheap bananas into our stores.  This can be done right now with relatively little effort and I encourage you to email me at kyledeb at gmail dot com if you want to help out.  Things like setting up a website, a petition, and designing fliers for people are definitley things that I'm looking for people to help me out with but I can't do it alone.

2. Buy Fair Trade Bananas -- Boycott Chiquita

There's a lot to be said about the effectiveness of boycotts but I think this specific case merits a call for a boycott.  The fact that Chiquita's revenue went up 3% this last quarter is unnacceptable considering they just plead guilty to supporting organizations responsible for the death and suffering of so many people in Colombia.  Some people have suggested not eating bananas at all but I think the most helpful route is to buy fair trade bananas.  Here's a Boston Globe article on fair trade bananas, and this is my favorite fair trade banana company, Oke USA.

3. Seek Justice

I've used the battle call "Extradite Chiquita Executives" in this section just because I believe it is shocking enough to grab people's attention.  Recently, though, I've had reason to believe that there might be some actual progress in this area.  There is definitely more on this to come but in the meantime I suggest you support two different things that have the potential to be really explosive.

Lawyer William J. Wichmann is helping 22 families sue Chiquita on behalf of family members that died in the conflict in Colombia.  We should support this in anyway that we can.

Congressman Bill Delahunt recently chaired a committee inquiring into U.S. business ties in Colombia and I suggest we support his efforts in anyway that we can.

I really think we can make a difference here and I appreciate any help I can get with this.  The following are the first 20 blogs that have spoken out against Chiquita, directly or indirectly as a result of this campaign.

1. Burnzpost
2. Jottings
3. Video Store Blues
4. Eleanor Duckwall
5. Blog4Brains
6. Elevator Up
7. One Step Closer
8. Islamophobia Watcher
9. The Garlic
10. aTypical Joe

11. Vox Ameliae
12. NoisyRoom
13. Samadhisoft
14. Writeous Sister Speaks
15. Chromed Curses
16. Lucky White Girl
17. Foreign Perpectives
18. Desde Kinshasa
19. Why Am I Not Surprised
20. Crooks and Liars

Comments

  • Re: Seek Justice For Chiquita



  • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

    I don´t know all the details of this case, but how is it different from American businesses paying protection money to the ´mob´.  Should the businesses be prosecuted?  Are they prosecuted in the US? 


    • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

      I actually don't know how protection payments to the mob are dealt with.  The difference in this case though is that the paramilitary group Chiquita paid, the AUC, was a specially designated terrorist organization by the U.S. government.  The U.S. invades countries to fight terrorism and Chiquita gets off with a $25 million fine?


      • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

        I don´t think that who the US designates as terrorists is necessarily rational.  I don´t want to be in the position of defending AUC - but they seem to behave more like a criminal organisation than a terrorist organisation.


        • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

          The Secretary of State specially designated the AUC as a terrorist group in 2001 and President Bush also designated it as a terrorist group in 2003.  I agree with you in the sense that "terrorism" is an extremely broad term, and I am certainly not in favor of war on a concept that can be so easily manipulated to fit the interests of the elite.  Still the very same people that have waged war on two countries to fight "terrorism" have designated the AUC as "terrorist" and I believe this case more than any other illustrates the hypocrisy of U.S. foreign policy and global inequity in general.  As I always say we need to start caring for everybody if we want to protect ourselves.

          While I see the issues your raising, I do not think it is an accurate characterization to identify the AUC as simply a criminal organization.  I recommend you read up more on the AUC.  The AUC has been responsible for massive campaigns againt the indigenous population of Colombia.  In Colombia about half the atrocities against the local population are committed by right wing paramilitarys, only 2% of the atrocities are committed by left wing armed groups, and the rest of it is actually committed by government forces.  This is a lot of why so many government officials are going down in Colombia for their paramilitary involvement.  This is more than a criminal organization, it is engaged in extralegal warfare against the citizens of Colombia.


          • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

            I didn't say that AUC is 'simply' a criminal organization.  My point in commenting on this is that it is commonplace in Colombia for businesses to pay 'taxes' to AUC, FARC, ELN - whoever happens to control the area they are in.  It doesn't mean that the business owners like it, or 'support' the group they are paying.  As I said I don't know the details of the Chiquita case, but the allegations I have read are that they paid AUC,  unlike Drummond, who are accused of using the AUC to further their business interests - a totally different matter. 

            Has Chiquita been accused, or better yet convicted, of using the AUC, or simply paying them 'taxes' or protection.



            • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

              There have been serious allegations made against Chiquita that they actually used their boats to transport over 3,000 assault rifles, that they used their boats to traffic drugs, and if you don't think paying $2 million to the AUC gives Chiquita a lot of say in who they get to terrorize or kill you're not making sense.


              • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

                OK.  Who did Chiquita ask the AUC to terrorize or kill?


                • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

                  If that's the way you interpreted my words than I take the blame.  I do not know of anyone specifically that they have asked to terrorize or kill, but I do know that they would have massive say in anything that the AUC did with those kind of payments.  I don't believe Chiquita did not have anything to do with AUCs actions after the payments.  Chiquita executives might have been ignorant of the specifics, but I'm certain security payments, often meant terrorizing the companies enemies.   That's just the way it works in Colombia.  I appreciate this conversation but it would help me if you identified yourself in someway to make sure that it is the same person that I'm speaking with.


                  • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

                    You seem like a very nice, well-intentioned person, and you may be right – you probably are.  But, as far as I can tell, all you know is that Chiquita paid money to AUC.  You can speculate about how they may have influenced the AUC -  maybe it was for the worse or maybe it was for the better, you don’t know. 

                     

                    It is not surprising to me that this has not been picked up by the press in a big way.  It would be a story if you could report that a big company operating in rural Colombia didn’t pay one of the terrorist groups. 

                     

                    Maybe it would be a more interesting story to know why Chiquita is being thrown to the wolves.  Maybe someone has an interest in seeing Chiquita have a hard time in Colombia?  Maybe a bunch of corrupt government and military officials have been using the paras to acquire banana lands (sell it to me or I’ll buy it from your widow) and they don’t want competition?  Maybe they will be more brutal than Chiquita?  Maybe you are just playing into their hand and making things worse. 

                     

                    I don’t like the AUC, and Chiquita are probably a bunch of bastards, but I feel a bit sorry for people and companies operating in Colombia, particularly in the 90’s.  I mean what choice did they have?  The real guilty party in my view is the Colombian government – why weren’t/aren’t they providing security.  The AUC would not have existed if the government had provided security.

                     

                     That's it for me dude - good luck



                    • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

                      I appreciate this exchange, but I feel it would have been more genuine of you to express your opinion at the beginning instead of going about it in this roundabout way.  You have access to the same information that I do and while I probably haven't done the best job making the case against chiquita in my exchange with you, I will continue to do so on Immigration Orange.

                      So your opinion, I take it after this long exchange, is that it's the Colombian government's fault.  I really have a problem with this view.  It smacks of elitism and it is an excuse for inaction.  If you really believe this is the Colombian government's fault I encourage you to do something about it instead of using it as an excuse to allow this suffering to continue.  I encourage you to email the attorney general of Colombia who is doing a better job than anyone else has in history of enforcing laws.

                      For the U.S. to throw all of the blame on this on Colombia is the same arrogance that makes the world hate the U.S. so much.  The U.S. is complicit in Colombia's suffering.  The drug money that is funding all of this suffering, comes almost entirely from U.S. citizens.  Elite U.S. citizens, at that, that are able to fund expensive cocaine and heroine habits.  The fact that the U.S. has dealt a relatively lenient judgement with respect to its own corporations, all while it helps it in an EU trade row, also shows the U.S.'s complicity.  You blame the Colombian government for its lack of security, but the U.S. has taken the responsbility for securing Colombia as well.  Unfortunately the funding they provide almost exclusively provides protection for multinational corporations in the are rather than protecting the Colombian people.  It might sound like this is coming from a leftist lunatic but this is the truth and conservatives and liberals knowledgable about the region will tell you that the U.S. fund a battalion exclusively for the protection of a petrochemical company in the region. 

                      It might seem that I am judging the U.S. to harshly on this, but the reason I provide this viewpoint is exclusively for people like you that so quickly put the blame on other countries.  We have to develop a new sense of global reponsibility where we don't stop caring and acting when our border ends and another begins.  I am extremely critical of U.S. foreign policy because it is not accountable to anyone and very few U.S. citizens care enough to do something about things like this.

                      Just to be clear, though, I admire the principles the U.S. was founded on, namely " We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."  I really feel the U.S. represents the greatest hope for a more just global society.  But I will continue to be critical precisely because of viewpoints like yours that abdicate themselves from the global responsibility that is thrust upon them.


                      • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

                        As I said initially, I didn't know the facts of the case - I was trying to find out what exactly Chiquita did - the lazy way. 

                        I agree with much of what you have said.   But I don't think you should let the Colombian elites off so easily. Why don't you take this up with the US gov't then. 

                        By the way, to dispel a couple more of your assumptions -I  am not American and I live in Colombia



                        • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

                          Thanks for dispelling my assumptiong but it always helps when you identify yourself even if it's just initials, like KD.  I direct a lot of my comments at U.S. readers here since that is where most come from, but if this were a Colombian blog I would be attacking the Colombian elites for the injustices they perpetuate as well.  I just recently spoke out against racism in Latin American which I am sure exists in Colombia as well.


                    • Leonid



                    • Joosepi



            • Joosepi



        • Illedan



        • Illedan



        • Leonid



        • Leonid



        • Leonid



      • Illedan



      • Illedan



      • Illedan



      • Illedan



    • Ivan



    • Ivan



  • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

    The word is spreading and newspapers are writing about it here in Sweden. I´ve written about it on my blog. Sorry since I only write in swedish. http://www.rabulist.se


    • Re: Seek Justice Against Chiquita

      The news is definitely spreading as newspapers are starting to put the pieces together on this.  I look forward to when consumers start putting the pieces together as well.


    • Joosepi



    • Joosepi



    • Joosepi



  • Ivan



  • Emily



  • David



  • David



  • Mark



  • John



  • John



  • Julia



  • Nick



  • Julia



  • Nick



  • Nick



  • Nick



  • Julia



  • Julia



  • David



  • George



  • George



  • George



  • George



  • http://shrinkurl.us/ZQl







search this blog